Dispelling Thermal Comfort Myths, Part 2

Air Movement, Humidity, Diversity and Models in Practice

BY ASIT KUMAR MISHRA, PH.D., ASSOCIATE MEMBER ASHRAE; ROBERT BEAN, FELLOW/LIFE MEMBER ASHRAE

 

ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55-2023, Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy,1 defines thermal comfort as “that condition of mind that expresses satisfaction with the thermal environment and is assessed by subjective evaluation.” As discussed in Part 1 (ASHRAE Journal, May 2026), this encompasses six primary factors—four
environmental parameters and two personal factors—and, under certain conditions, additional local discomfort criteria. Part 1 focused on myths involving indoor air quality (IAQ), load calculations, thermostats and setpoints. Part 2 addresses four myths that directly affect day-to-day design choices: assumptions about still air, the role of humidity, perceived gender bias and concerns about whether the predicted mean vote (PMV) model works in practice. The discussion then extends to local discomfort, adaptive comfort strategies and energy and sustainability considerations.

The Myths (Continued)
Myth 5: Still Air is Always Preferred for Comfort
HVAC design often aims to minimize air movement in occupied spaces; drafts are universally undesirable.

Reality
Air movement for cooling effects can significantly enhance perceptions of thermal comfort when properly applied.2 ASHRAE Standard 55-2023’s elevated air speed method allows higher operative temperatures when air speeds exceed 0.2 m/s (40 fpm), provided occupants have control over the air movement. At air speeds of 0.8 m/s (160 fpm), the acceptable operative temperature can increase by approximately 3°C (5.4°F). This principle underlies ceiling fan and personal cooling device effectiveness in reducing energy consumption while maintaining conditions for comfort.3

Practical Implications
• Consider elevated air speed strategies to expand comfort zones and reduce energy use in cooling applications.

• Provide occupant control over air movement when possible.
• Evaluate draft risk carefully—air movement is beneficial when occupants feel warm, but problematic when they feel cool.

Myth 6: Humidity is Secondary to Temperature
Many practitioners focus primarily on controlling air temperature, while treating humidity as a secondary concern.

Reality
Humidity is a nuanced element tied to air temperature and can significantly affect sensation and perception of thermal comfort. It is one of the four primary environmental factors in ASHRAE Standard 55-2023.
However, the standard does not specify a maximum or minimum humidity level based solely on thermal comfort considerations. This might initially seem to reduce humidity’s importance, but reality is more nuanced. For example, 60% relative humidity (RH) at 24°C (75°F) creates different evaporative cooling conditions than 60% RH at 28°C (82°F).

Very low humidity environments can cause skin drying, irritation of mucus membranes, drying of eyes and static electricity generation—all factors that affect occupant satisfaction even if thermal comfort criteria are met. Conversely, very high humidity creates conditions favorable for mold growth, dust mite proliferation and microbial activity that compromise both IAQ and long-term building durability.4,5

Practical Implications
• Include, when necessary, humidity control in thermal comfort strategies.
• Consider latent load management in hot, humid climates.
• Assess humidity and dehumidification strategies in naturally ventilated buildings and consider mixed mode systems.
• Recognize that humidity control may be more critical than temperature control in some climates and situations.

Myth 7: ASHRAE Standard 55 is Gender-Biased Against Women
One of the most widespread misconceptions suggests that ASHRAE Standard 55 is biased toward male office workers and sets temperatures too low for women’s comfort preferences.

Reality
ASHRAE Standard 55 is explicitly gender neutral. The PMV/PPD (predicted percentage of dissatisfied) index used in the standard is based on the European ISO 7730 Standard, which incorporated studies with equal numbers of men and women of various ages. ASHRAE’s 2015 media rebuttal regarding the bias misconception clearly states: “The basic research for establishing comfort criteria for the indoor environment was made with more than 1,000 subjects with equal
amounts of women and men.”6 When differences in thermal preference between genders are observed in field studies, they are primarily attributed to clothing choices. Women often wear lighter clothing than men in office environments, naturally leading to preferences for warmer temperatures. The standard accounts for this through its clothing insulation parameter (clo values), which should be adjusted based on actual occupant clothing patterns.

Practical Implications
• Consider actual clothing patterns relevant to your design, not stereotypical assumptions.
• Use the dynamic clothing insulation model when appropriate.
• Use different representative occupant assessments to flesh out potential conflicts between clothing choices.
Discuss the benefits of clothing choice flexibility in policy and operations.
• Enable the use of personal thermal comfort solutions such as heaters.
• Address the root causes of thermal discomfort through assessment of the architectural, enclosure and interior system designs and with appropriate HVAC system selection and design.

Myth 8: The PMV Model Doesn’t Work in Practice
Some practitioners dismiss the PMV model as inaccurate for real-world applications, citing discrepancies between predicted and actual thermal sensations.

Reality
PMV “inaccuracies” are more likely to stem from incorrect or uninformed input assumptions than from model deficiencies. The model requires accurate values for all comfort parameters, and errors in clothing insulation or metabolic rate estimates can significantly affect results, especially when local factors have been ignored.
Research shows measurement error reduces PMV accuracy by 20% to 25%,7 but the model remains valid when proper
inputs are used. The key is understanding model limitations and applying the model appropriately,8 such as using accurate clothing and activity estimates, and measuring or calculating mean radiant temperature properly. Depending on
the envisaged use of the space, consider temporal variations in occupancy and conditions. Where appropriate, apply
the adaptive comfort model for naturally ventilated buildings.

Practical Implications
• Invest time to improve accuracy of input parameters. FIGURE 1 Myths dispelled—a summary.
• Use the model as a design tool to influence architecture, enclosure interior and HVAC systems and not as a precise predictor of occupant thermal discomfort.
• Validate assumptions through post-occupancy evaluation when possible.
• Consider adaptive comfort and mixed-mode approaches for naturally ventilated spaces.

Discussion 
Building on the foundational issues addressed in Part 1, myths about still air, humidity, gender bias and the PMV model further illustrate how partial or misapplied knowledge can undermine both occupant experience and energy performance. Success in thermal comfort design requires moving beyond simple air temperature control to a comprehensive understanding of heat transfer between the human body and the environment.

Understanding Local Thermal Discomfort
Beyond the two personal factors (clothing insulation [clo] and metabolic rate [met]) and four general factors (primary comfort factors—air temperature [ta], mean radiant temperature [MRT], humidity [H] and air velocity [V ]), ASHRAE Standard 55 addresses several local discomfort sources that can cause dissatisfaction even when general comfort conditions are met. Local factors must be assessed when met rates are less than 1.3 (e.g., standing relaxed) and
clothing less than 0.7 (e.g., sleeveless blouse and skirt); these factors are1:

• Radiant temperature asymmetry. People are particularly sensitive to having divergent surface-to surface and surface-to-air temperatures across their bodies and specifically sensitive to warm ceilings and cold walls.
• Draft and air movement. Unwanted air movement can cause discomfort, especially in the head/neck and
ankle region. However, desired air movement enhances cooling comfort. The key is providing occupant control
and avoiding excessive air speeds when occupants feel neutral or cool.
• Vertical air temperature differences. Temperature stratification can cause discomfort when the difference
between head and ankle level is excessive. A graph representing the influence from stratification is included in the standard.

•Floor surface temperature. Floor temperatures should remain between 19°C – 29°C (66°F – 84°F) for occupants wearing typical indoor footwear.

Conclusion
Taken together, the eight myths addressed across Parts 1 and 2 (Figure 1) demonstrate how easily thermal comfort design can be derailed by oversimplifications: conflating IAQ and comfort, treating load calculations as comfort calculations,
trusting thermostats and single setpoints, undervaluing air movement and humidity, misattributing discomfort to gender bias in the standard or dismissing the PMV model outright.
Designing for thermal comfort requires embracing the comprehensive approach outlined in ASHRAE Standard 55-2023. Success depends on understanding the interactions between all comfort parameters and applying them appropriately for specific building types, climates and occupant characteristics. By dispelling these myths, practitioners can:

• Approach thermal environments from an integrated perspective, relying first on passive solutions found within architecture, enclosures and interior systems.
• Be strategic in selecting mechanical systems, matching solutions to the problem. For example, if cold floors are the problem, no utility exists in an air based solution: choose insulated and heated floors. If humidity is the problem in a high-performance enclosure, then use dedicated dehumidification instead of adding sensible capacity to the cooling
system.
• Reduce energy consumption while maintaining conditions for thermal comfort.
• Avoid costly post-occupancy comfort problems.
• Create buildings that truly serve occupant needs.
• The path forward requires education, proper tool use and a commitment to evidence-based design practices. ASHRAE Standard 55-2023 provides the foundation—practitioners must build upon it with careful analysis, appropriate application, continuous learning and by embracing the underlying ethos of the Standard.

References
1. ANSI/ASHRAE, Standard 55-2023, Thermal Environmental Conditions For Human Occupancy.
2. Arens, E., S. Turner, H. Zhang, G. Paliaga. 2009. “Moving air for comfort.” ASHRAE Journal 51(5):18 – 28.
3. Mora, R., R. Bean, K. Kokubun, M. Grieger. 2018. “Thermal comfort: Designing for people.” ASHRAE Journal 60(2):40 – 49.
4. Baughman, A. E.A. Arens. 1996. “Indoor humidity and human health—Part I: Literature review of health effects of humidity influenced indoor pollutants.” ASHRAE Transactions: 193 – 211. https://tinyurl.com/4du7sx9n
5. Arundel, A.V., E.M. Sterling, J.H. Biggin, T. D. Sterling. 1986. “Indirect health effects of relative humidity in indoor
environments.” Environmental Health Perspectives 65:351 – 361. https:// doi.org/10.2307/3430203
6. Olesen, B. 2015. “ASHRAE Statement in Response to Nature Climate Change Article on Thermal Comfort.” ASHRAE Media Release.
7. Charles, K.E. 2003. “Fanger’s Thermal Comfort and Draught Models.” Institute for Research in Construction, National Research Council Canada.
8. Mishra, A.K., P. Wargocki, E.J. O’Reilly. 2025. “Are we adequately accounting for human factors in analyses of thermal comfort studies?” Energy Buildings:116335.
9. De Dear, R.J. G.S. Brager. 2002. “Thermal comfort in naturally ventilated buildings: revisions to ASHRAE Standard 55.” Energy Buildings 34(6):549 – 561.
10. Simmonds, P. 2022. “Using ASHRAE Standard 55 adaptive comfort method for practical applications.” CLIMA 2022 Conference. https://tinyurl.com/yr2cceaj

Asit Kumar Mishra, Ph.D., is research fellow, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
Robert Bean, RET, P.L..(Eng.) is a retired practitioner from Alberta, Canada.

Published in ASHRAE JOURNAL ashrae.org JUNE 2026, download here